Reminiscences of a Stock Operator
Fictionalised account of Jesse Livermore, serialised in the Saturday Evening Post 1922-23.
Summary
Lefevre published this in 1923 as a fictionalised account of Jesse Livermore, then the most famous speculator in America, presented through the narrator Larry Livingston. It is based on extended interviews and Livermore later acknowledged the accuracy of the portrayal, though it should be read as a novel rather than as a memoir.
The book follows the career from the bucket shops of Boston, where Livingston learned to read the tape and was eventually barred for winning, through repeated cycles of building fortunes and losing them. The 1907 panic, where he made three million dollars in a day shorting, and the 1906 Union Pacific trade before the San Francisco earthquake, are the set pieces.
The trading lessons are stated repeatedly and directly. The big money is made in the big move and not in the fluctuations, which requires sitting still after a position is right. A trader should trade with the general market direction rather than against it. Losses should be cut quickly and positions should be added to only when they show a profit. Tips, inside information and other people's opinions destroy accounts. The market's behaviour, not the trader's reasoning, determines whether a position is correct.
Livingston also describes the manipulation practices of the era, including pool operations and distribution through the tape, which were legal then and are not now. s The book gives no system and its methods depend on tape reading in a market structure that no longer exists. Livermore himself went bankrupt several times and shot himself in 1940, which readers should weigh against the advice. Its durability comes from the psychological description, which traders across a century have recognised.
Key takeaways 8
- The large profits come from holding a correct position through a long move, not from trading the fluctuations within it.
- Most traders lose because they cannot sit still when they are right, and activity feels like work while patience does not.
- A position should be increased only after it shows a profit, and averaging down into a loss is the error that destroys accounts.
- The market's price action, not the trader's analysis, determines whether a position is correct, so a losing position should be closed before the reasoning is re-examined.
- Trading against the general direction of the market produces losses even when the analysis of the individual security is right.
- Tips and inside information are worthless because the person supplying them has their own position and their own reasons.
- Every speculator's mistakes are their own, and blaming manipulation, brokers or news prevents the correction that would improve results.
- There is nothing new in markets, because the same patterns recur whenever the same human responses to money are involved.
Who should read it
Traders and investors who want the classic account of speculative psychology, read as a novel and with awareness that Livermore's own record ended in ruin.
About Edwin Lefevre
Financial journalist and novelist; chronicler of Wall Street, 1901-1943
Reminiscences of a Stock Operator is the primary source nearly every later trading book quotes.
Who recommended it 8 · 7 direct
“The finest trading book ever written is Reminiscences of a Stock Operator by Edwin LeFevre. It is colloquial reminiscences by a legendary speculator of the mistakes and lessons he learned over a…”
“For a long time, I used to read Reminiscences of a Stock Operator almost every year.”
“When I was 17 I was backpacking across Europe. I was in Rome and had run out of books to read. The only book they had in English was Reminiscences of a Stock Operator. It's the only possession in…”
“Everyone had to read, because it's such great history, Edwin Lefevre's Reminiscences of a Stock Operator.”
“My favourite book on investing is Reminiscences of a Stock Operator. It was first published in 1923 and is filled with the jargon of the day. You realize that nothing has changed. It is still just…”
“It is a textbook for trading. I hand a copy to every new trader we have.”
Similar books 6
Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.
What markets looked like at the US stock bottoms of 1921, 1932, 1949 and 1982.
A value investor's memoir from the 1950s to the dot-com crash, on market psychology.
“Personal biographies, the histories, are the most interesting. I have Benjamin Graham's personal biography, also the biography of Leon Levy, The Mind of Wall Street. These are all great.” — Chris Mittleman
Source: Mittleman on why investor biographies are the most useful reading
Recommended by: Chris Mittleman
Why Wall Street grows rich on fees while its clients' results stay ordinary.
“recommended reading for those with a healthy disdain for Wall Street and its practices as well as an interest in post-boom psychology” — Nick Sleep
Source: Nomad Investment Partnership, Interim Report for the period ended June 30th, 2002, p. 10
Recommended by: Mohnish Pabrai, Nick Sleep, Warren Buffett and 4 others
Data showing that low-expectation stocks beat popular ones over the long run.
“all these people really were helpful in forming and getting me involved in investing” — Joel Greenblatt
Source: Masters in Business transcript: Joel Greenblatt (2018)
Recommended by: Joel Greenblatt, Mohnish Pabrai and 1 other
Markets as a game of crowd psychology, seen through 1960s go-go Wall Street.
“One of the great books about investing is Adam Smith's 'The Money Game' which was published in 1967.” — Barton Biggs
Source: Biggs on one of the great books about investing
Recommended by: Barton Biggs, Howard Marks, Mohnish Pabrai and 5 others
Value investing joined with behavioural finance, from a strategist's research notes.
Recommended by: Mohnish Pabrai
Where it sits in the reference 6
Topics