Updates

  1. 137 new fund letters and reports, each with its own page: Kayne Anderson Rudnick (48 market briefings, KayneCast episodes and TV commentaries), Shelton Capital Management (48 shareholder reports and a commentary), Lakehouse Capital (10 Small Companies Fund letters), Smead (5 newsletters), RIT Capital Partners (5 monthly commentaries), Kovitz, Legal & General, Generation, Hosking, Marram, Munro, Oldfield and others.
  2. 200 new fund letters and reports, each with its own page: Spheria (41 monthly reports), Peapack Private (41 weekly recaps and planning newsletters), Fort Washington (23), Polen Capital (15), Aristotle Pacific (14), Riverwater (13), Chou (10), Apollo Asia Fund (8, back to 1998), Personal Asset Trust, Rockwood Strategic, J Capital Research, I/O Fund, Penn Davis McFarland, Pomona and others.
  3. Investor pages have one Investments tab with shares, changes, % owned, class, market cap and Market cap and Status filters, a Funds tab listing each fund the firm runs, and assets under management from Form ADV. The Investors table shows AUM and current investments, and its search finds investors by what they hold.
  4. Filters, search and sort stay as you left them when you come back to a section. Person cards look like book cards. Company pages name their Investors tab Ownership. Kind and Sector filters use four kinds and GICS sectors with industries. Dead links left the Links tabs.
  5. 190 more investors from fiscal.ai's list, with their sites, letters, partners and 13F holdings; 556 more partner descriptions. Experts now lists only people.
  6. Fund letters lists 144 new documents from 23 firms, each with its own page: a summary, key insights and quotes. Among them: 37 BlackRock articles, 21 Value Partners monthly notes, eight Baron Capital letters, six Stone Sentinel letters to partners, seven Value Line portfolio manager Q&As, BNY's 2026 earnings releases and Starboard Value's 2026 conference presentations.
  7. 584 more investors, with their websites, 6,776 letters from their own sites, 1,385 partners with pages and the 13F holdings of 213 firms. New letters arrive daily from 290 more archives.
  8. Media and Companies filter by GICS sector and industry group, taken from the companies an episode or page names. 1,860 more company pages show a logo, the SEC's list included.
  9. The home page counts what the platform holds and lists features such as the document reader, the player and saved marks. Settings sits at the foot of the rail. Book cards are a quarter wider, so rows hold fewer. Companies drops the Named in filter, and the Role list in your account runs A to Z.
  10. Investor pages of 13 firms show their newsroom's latest posts. New 13F filings are read as the SEC publishes them.
  11. Investor pages have an Investments tab: 13,975 holdings for 105 investors, from their 13F filings with the SEC and their own portfolio pages, with status and sector. 7,338 more companies have a page of their own.
  12. A podcast or YouTube episode keeps playing while you move around the site, in a bar with skip, speed and volume. Media tables show each episode's length and description.
  13. Press releases come from each company's own newsroom (167 companies); SEC filings sit on the Filings tab. Tickers name their exchange, and a company's Experts tab includes guests whose episode description names it.
  14. Letter types now include Market commentary, Fact sheet, Interim report, Annual report, Proxy circular and Governance document. The reader opens over the whole window.
  15. Partners of investment firms have 2,836 appearances and 580 pieces of writing on their pages; Derek Sivers's page lists every book he rates, with his rating.
  16. Fund letters lists three Akre Focus shareholder reports: the ETF's annual report for the year to July 2026, its semi-annual report to January 2026 and the fund's semi-annual report to January 2025, each with its own page: a summary, key insights and quotes.
  17. 837 partners of 73 investment firms now have their own pages, with title, description, photograph and social accounts; Andreessen Horowitz partners' pages also list their writing on a16z.com.
  18. Company pages have a Press releases tab: 8,229 releases for 203 companies, from SEC filings and company newsrooms. Companies filter by For-profit or Non-profit. Own media is a table with filters. Media filters by sector and industry. Publication pages link their publisher in the description.
  19. The Unilever page's Letters tab shows what each fund letter says about Unilever, word for word with its page, and whether the letter is bullish, bearish, mixed or neutral. Filter by sentiment, and see 10 letters at a time.
  20. 492 more fund letters and 3,183 more articles show the day they were published, read from each letter's first page or each article's own page.
  21. The PDF reader has a search box: type words to see every match in the document and step through them. About 540 letters that were web pages, among them Oakmark's commentaries, Bill Miller's letters and Howard Marks's memos, now open in the reader.
  22. Person pages: recommendations open with tier 1 books; one button per organisation; transcripts sit on their episodes; the books on 129 reading lists joined the Recommends tabs.
  23. Companies lists every company with a ticker on the SEC's list, with a Source filter. A quote on a company page opens the letter at that page with the words marked. A company's Media tab lists only episodes that name it, and a new Own media tab lists its podcasts, publications and YouTube channel. Show pages link their publisher. A page opened from a table no longer shows that table's filters beside it.
  24. Company, investor and person pages show more of their social accounts: Facebook, TikTok, Bluesky, Medium, GitHub, Discord and podcast shows. Investor pages list every partner the firm's own team page names: 965 people across 73 investors, 98 for Andreessen Horowitz.
  25. About 170 more letters and papers open in the reader: Mohnish Pabrai's letters and transcripts from his site's new folder, and free copies of papers by Asness, Harvey, Altman, Lo and others from their own or their schools' sites.
  26. Every company a fund letter names has a page, with the letters and quotes that name it: 47 new pages, among them Atom Computing, Hugging Face, Rolls-Royce Holdings and Westinghouse Electric. Company pages have a Quotes tab.
  27. A person's Writing tab has a Type column and filter (Article, Essay, Transcript, Speech, Foreword, Interview and the rest), and Publication names only the publication that published each piece.
  28. Fund letters opens on the newest published letter, and a letter or paper found by search opens its own page here instead of the publisher's site.
  29. A letter or paper with a copy on the site opens its PDF over its page, with a button to open it in a new tab. Select text to highlight or underline it; signed-in readers keep their marks in their account. Each quote opens the PDF at its page with its words marked, and a Source link leads to the publisher's original.
  30. Fund letters lists 61 more documents, each with its own page: Fairfax's 2025 and 2026 interim reports, proxy circulars and 2025 annual report (with their French editions), 26 Charlie Munger meeting transcripts, talks and essays, Third Point's 2026 monthly reports and Malibu Life's interim results, and a Seth Klarman interview. Papers adds Richard Thaler's two 2020 editorials on nudges.
  31. Fund letters lists Lux Capital's letters for Q2 and Q3 2026, by Josh Wolfe, each with its own page: a summary, key insights and quotes.
  32. Fund letters lists Brookfield's letter to shareholders for Q3 2026, by Bruce Flatt, with its own page: a summary, key insights and quotes.
  33. Fund letters lists Howard Marks's memo of 11 November 2026, A Layman Thinks About AI, with its own page: a summary, key insights and quotes.
  34. Fund letters lists 118 more letters, each with its own page: 44 weekly commentaries by Jeremy Siegel from 2026, 31 issues of Van Tharp's newsletter from 2018, 23 Pabrai Investment Funds letters from 2021 to Q3 2026, 13 Efficient Frontier essays by William Bernstein, Oakmark's three 3Q 2026 commentaries, two Lindsell Train reports, a John Hussman comment and Third Point's Q3 2026 letter.
  35. 2,027 more books carry a one-line description in the Books table and on their pages; 7,067 of 7,715 have one, every tier 1, 2 and 3 book among them.
  36. Fund letters lists 187 more letters from 19 firms, among them Permanent Equity, Social Capital, Lux Capital, Square Peg, Bestinver, Cobas, Sequoia Fund, Marketfield and EquityCompass; each shows on its investor's page and has a page of its own.
  37. 2,928 more books carry a one-line description in the Books table and on their pages, so every tier 1, 2 and 3 book has one; 5,040 in all.
  38. Every publication on Newsletters has its own page: its writing, its writers, its staff and who recommends it. Investor pages have a Management tab; a company's Experts tab now leaves out its own people, who list under Management. Tabs on a phone move sideways only.
  39. Every fund letter and research paper has its own page: the thesis, the PDF, the companies and books it names, and for 176 letters and 24 papers so far a summary, key insights and quotes with their page.
  40. 99 books that no page listed now sit under their topics in Books, among them Caste, American Prometheus and Pale Blue Dot.
  41. Newsletters lists every newspaper, magazine, investment newsletter, journal and blog the reference holds, 442 in all, with the people who write there. The search box keeps your last 20 searches. You can create an account.
  42. 283 books that fund managers recommend in their letters are on the shelf, each with the letter's own words and page; investor pages have a Recommends tab.
  43. Person, company, investor and show pages link their own accounts on X, Threads, Instagram, LinkedIn, YouTube and Substack: 275 people, 552 companies and organisations, 88 investors and 478 shows.
  44. 716 more book recommendations name their source: the person's own reading list, letter, blog post, speech or interview, or an article that reports it. 232 of them quote the person's own words about the book, on the book card and on the book's page.
  45. Every US-listed company has a page with its SEC filings. Company pages list their experts and their management, past and present. Fund managers sit under Investors. Each show has a page of its episodes, and an episode page names its guests and hosts. Biographies lists groups, then people. Breadcrumbs show where a page sits.
  46. Media lists every podcast episode, video, interview and talk, over 10,000, by person, company, publisher and event; each filter searches its own choices. Books opens on its table, then Browse, then Authors and Recommenders. A filter's count no longer covers its arrow.
  47. A book that no company, country or subject page lists shows its topics under Where it sits in the reference. On a phone, a page's tabs scroll sideways only. Descriptions read the same on every page. See them in the Experts tab lists every expert the page names.
  48. Every podcast episode, video and interview has its own page with a video or audio player and a link to the source. Investor pages show each company's sector and market cap; firms such as Berkshire Hathaway have one page that holds their letters and their company tabs. Letters tabs filter by company and search the theses. Companies filter by Public, Private and Defunct and link each company's website.
  49. Every tab, view and search has its own address, such as /books/table/asset or /letters/companies, so Back works and a link opens the same place. Page addresses no longer end in .html. Fund letters, Investors, Companies and Papers load about a fifth of the data they did.
  50. Fund letters has a Companies tab: every company the letters name, with its market cap, sector, country, and how many letters and investors name it. Investor pages link each investor's website. Lists in table cells end with “… and N more” at every width.
  51. 1,120 more book summaries; descriptions for 373 papers; pages for 137 more companies, each with the fund letters that discuss it; 215 official photographs; search has its own page.
  52. 411 more books have a summary; person pages list 930 more of the books they wrote; 147 people show their official photograph.
  53. Every investor has a page with its letters and the companies they discuss; company pages list the investors whose letters name them.
  54. A Companies section at the top of the rail lists every company the books, experts and fund letters name.
  55. Person pages list letters, writing, profiles and links as sortable tables with filters, and show each person's companies as links; Fund letters show each letter's description in its own column.
  56. Experts show a checked job title and a short description of each person; 30 more people have photographs.
  57. Every company, fund, university and publication the experts work for has a page listing the people there.
  58. Fund letters show each letter's thesis and filter by it; 225 person pages list the essays, columns and newsletter issues the person wrote.
  59. Person pages list every essay and newsletter issue a person wrote, and their own books as a table in List view.
  60. Recommends shows the five largest kinds of book and the rest under More; browse pictures load sooner.
  61. Podcasts and talks link the original episode, filter by Audio and video or Press, and list each publisher once.
  62. Pages are wider, Recommends has List and Grid, and a filter clicked again turns off.
  63. Book cards sit in a ruled grid with Open Library and Goodreads links and each book's one-line note.
  64. Funds is now Investors; each investor's styles are buttons that filter the table.
  65. Podcasts and talks on a person's page filter by year and publisher and show as a list or a grid of pictures.
  66. Quotes show only people's own words: 472 summaries written by list sites are gone.
  67. Country pages open from Browse again, and every link on the shelf lands on a page.
  68. Subject and person pages show their sections as tabs, and each book appears once on a person's page.
  69. Book cards show the quote, who said it and the source; grids show five cards to a row.
  70. On a phone, a menu holds the sections, search, Updates, Feedback and dark mode.
  71. Feedback takes a screenshot of the page with no browser prompt, opens a screenshot full size when you click it, and clears itself once sent.
  72. Book cards are centred, search names the topic each book sits in, and any text cut short shows whole on hover.
  73. Search groups its results by kind: people, companies, geographies, subjects, topics, books, funds, fund letters and papers.
  74. The Books table lists who recommended each book by name, and the browser tab names the section you are in.
  75. Feedback can take a screenshot of the page, or one you paste or choose, and opens in the corner beside Updates.
  76. Each rail button reopens its section where you left it, and Browse, Table and People show on every book and subject page.
  77. Filters grey out choices that hold nothing instead of hiding them, and Books › People filters by authors or recommenders.
  78. Feedback takes a subject line and up to three screenshots.
  79. Biographies are grouped by the person they are about: 41 new pages, from Abraham Lincoln to Lee Kuan Yew.
  80. Sport splits into 23 sports, and Religion into one topic per faith.
  81. Book lists show as cards: the cover, one recommendation quote and every recommender by name.
  82. Seventeen subjects that had two or three pages under different names now have one page each.
  83. Every page lists its Experts as authors and recommenders, with a link to them on the Experts tab.
  84. Economics, Financial history, Financial panics and Accounting are subjects of their own, with one page per financial crisis.
  85. Book, person and subject pages open inside the app, so the tabs stay in view.
  86. 996 more book covers, and photographs or logos for 227 more people and companies.
  87. Books › Browse shows every subject as cards, and the rail holds Fund letters, Papers, Experts, Books and Funds.
  88. Every topic over 150 books splits into narrower topics, each with a page of its own.

Send feedback

What is it?
Screenshots, up to 3 (optional)
or paste one with Ctrl+V

We use your email only to reply to you.

The Evolution of Cooperation

The Evolution of Cooperation

Computer tournaments of the prisoner's dilemma show why tit-for-tat wins.

Robert Axelrod
1984
T1 241 pages · about 4h 1m to read Open Librarygoodreads

Summary

Axelrod ran computer tournaments in which submitted strategies played the iterated prisoner's dilemma against each other, and this book reports what won and why.

The winner in both tournaments was tit-for-tat, submitted by Anatol Rapoport, which cooperates on the first move and then copies the opponent's previous move. It was the shortest programme submitted. Axelrod identifies four properties that characterised successful strategies: being nice, meaning never defecting first; being retaliatory, meaning responding to defection immediately; being forgiving, meaning returning to cooperation as soon as the opponent does; and being clear, meaning simple enough that the opponent can recognise the pattern and adapt to it.

His theoretical result is that cooperation can emerge among self-interested agents without central authority or trust, provided the interaction is repeated and the shadow of the future is long enough, meaning the participants weight future encounters sufficiently relative to present gains.

The empirical applications include the live and let live system that developed in First World War trench warfare, where units facing each other across static lines developed tacit restraint that commands had to break up by rotating troops, and biological examples of reciprocal altruism.

The work has been enormously influential across biology, political science and economics. Later research has qualified it: tit-for-tat performs poorly with noise, since a single misperception produces endless mutual retaliation, and variants including generous tit-for-tat and win-stay-lose-shift do better in noisy environments.

Key takeaways 7

  1. Tit-for-tat, which cooperates first and then copies the opponent's last move, won both tournaments and was the shortest programme submitted.
  2. Successful strategies were nice, meaning they never defected first, retaliatory, forgiving and clear enough that opponents could recognise the pattern.
  3. Cooperation emerges among self-interested agents without authority or trust provided the interaction repeats and future encounters are weighted sufficiently.
  4. Extending the shadow of the future, by making interactions more frequent or more durable, promotes cooperation more reliably than any appeal to values.
  5. Being clear enough that an opponent can understand your strategy is an advantage, since a strategy that cannot be recognised cannot be reciprocated.
  6. Trench warfare units facing each other across static lines developed tacit restraint that commands had to break up by rotating troops.
  7. Tit-for-tat performs poorly with noise, since one misperception produces endless mutual retaliation, and forgiving variants do better in noisy environments.

Who should read it

Anyone designing repeated interactions, including negotiators, platform operators and partnership managers, who needs the conditions under which cooperation emerges.

Who recommended it 4 · 3 direct

“That clever but unsatisfying explanation eventually led me to the book and article that I'm recommending this year - The Evolution of Cooperation by Robert Axelrod, and a related journal article1 (jointly, "EoC").”

“Robert Axelrod, The Evolution of Cooperation (New York: Basic Books, 1984)”

“For game theory, in addition to playing strategy games, you may want to try The Compleat Strategyst: Being a Primer on the Theory of Games of Strategy by J.D. Williams and The Evolution of Cooperation by Robert Axelrod.”

Similar books 6

Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.

William Poundstone · 1992

Von Neumann, game theory and the prisoner's dilemma in nuclear strategy.

“For international relations, see William Poundstone, Prisoner’s Dilemma (New York: Doubleday, 1992)” — Michael Mauboussin

Source: The Colonel Blotto Game: Transitivity and How to Win When You’re an Underdog, page 8

Recommended by: Michael Mauboussin

Avinash K. Dixit, Barry J. Nalebuff · 2008

Game theory without maths, with new examples: commitment, signals, bargaining.

“for business, see Avinash K. Dixit and Barry J. Nalebuff, The Art of Strategy (New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 2008)” — Michael Mauboussin

Source: The Colonel Blotto Game: Transitivity and How to Win When You’re an Underdog, page 8

Recommended by: Michael Mauboussin, Marc Andreessen

Avinash K. Dixit, Barry J. Nalebuff · 1991

Game theory without maths: look forward, reason back, and make threats credible.

“Avinash K. Dixit and Barry J. Nalebuff, Thinking Strategically (New York: W. W. Norton & Co., 1991)” — Michael Mauboussin

Source: Measuring the Moat: Assessing the Magnitude and Sustainability of Value Creation, page 47

Recommended by: Jim Collins, Michael Mauboussin

Robert Wright · 2000

History as a growing web of non-zero-sum games, in which both sides can gain.

“His book Nonzero is among my five favorite books of all time. So, that book came out recently, and I gave that to my closest friend and my family.” — Nick Thompson

Source: The Tim Ferriss Show Transcripts: Nick Thompson (#311)

Recommended by: Mohnish Pabrai, Nick Thompson, Ev Williams and 1 other

Thomas C. Schelling · 1960

Conflict as bargaining: commitment, credible threats and focal points.

Recommended by: Naval Ravikant

John von Neumann, Oskar Morgenstern · 1944

The founding of game theory: expected utility and strategy among interacting players.

“John von Neumann and Oskar Morgenstern, Theory of Games and Economic Behavior (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1944)” — Michael Mauboussin

Source: Competitive Advantage Period: The Neglected Value Driver

Recommended by: Michael Mauboussin

Where it sits in the reference 2

Mental models
Mental models

Topics 4

Mathematics and StatisticsSociology and CultureSocial behaviour and collective actionGames, gambling and quantitative finance