The Advantage

Lencioni argues that organisational health, meaning the absence of politics and confusion and the presence of clarity and cohesion, matters more to performance than intelligence, strategy or technology, and that executives ignore it because it seems soft and cannot be reduced to a metric.

He sets out four disciplines. Build a cohesive leadership team, which requires the vulnerability-based trust, productive conflict and commitment from his earlier work. Create clarity by answering six questions as a team: why we exist, how we behave, what we do, how we will succeed, what is most important right now, and who must do what. Overcommunicate that clarity, on the argument that leaders stop repeating a message long before employees have internalised it, and that seven repetitions is a reasonable floor. Reinforce clarity through human systems, meaning hiring, performance management, compensation and firing must all encode the same answers.

The most practical elements are the six questions and the thematic goal concept, which is a single rallying objective with a defined time horizon that the whole leadership team shares regardless of function. Lencioni also argues for a specific meeting structure separating daily check-ins, weekly tactical, monthly strategic and quarterly offsite, with a rule that tactical and strategic matters must never be mixed in one meeting.

The book has no empirical base. Lencioni works from consulting experience and the evidence is assertion and illustrative example. The arguments about repetition and about meeting structure are useful and testable; the claim that health beats strategy is stated rather than demonstrated. The writing is repetitive by design and readers who know his earlier books will find substantial overlap.

American management consultant and founder of The Table Group; writes business fables about executive teams and organisational health.

The Five Dysfunctions of a Team names a sequence - absence of trust, fear of conflict, lack of commitment, avoidance of accountability, inattention to results - and gives managers a diagnostic order for working through them. The Advantage sets out organisational health as a measurable executive discipline covering clarity, meeting design and internal communication.

The Table Group